Date	Source	Rating	Quote
May 19	Hollywood Reporter	N/A	will try to hold onto the lead-in from Drew
May 24	MediaWeek	N/A	perfect companion to Drew
May 28	USA Today	N/A	TV's name game
July 30	USA Today		better-than-average
August 15	Rolling Stone Magazine	N/A	Apparently, hilarity will ensue.
September 9	TV Guide Fall Preview		slick yet almost suffocatingly sarcastic
September 10	Entertainment Weekly		Suggested alternate title: Oh Shut Up
September 14	Star Magazine	N/A	It's all crazy
September 14	US Magazine		stinker
September 15	Mr. Showbiz (internet)		write ABC a letter of disapproval
September 15	Long Beach Press-Tel		has potential
September 19	Charlotte Observer		human punch-line machines
September 19	Rolling Stone Magazine		kind of grows on you
September 20	JAM! (internet)		Total dud
September 21	Kansas City Star		shows promise of maturing
September 22	New York Times		you'll swear you're already tired of it
September 22	Washington Post		Sitcom No. 6475ABC99-B
September 22	New York Post		Mom's no Eddie
September 22	San Francisco Chronicle		I thought I'd die
September 22	Boston Globe		pathetic lines only the laugh track adores
September 22	Hollywood Reporter		falls completely flat
September 22	Los Angeles Daily News		any artistic statement is highly unlikely
September 22	Cincinnati Post		lackluster
September 22	Philadelphia Daily News		Oh, grow up
September 22	Seattle Post-Intelligencer		could lead to mild chuckling
September 22	Chicago Sun Times		not a bad show, just not a great one
September 22	Pittsburgh Post-Gazette		fares better than last fall's stinker
September 22	San Francisco Examiner		more laughs than expected
September 22	USA Today		humorous new life into an old concept
September 22	New York Daily News		snappily written and brashly performed
September 23	New York Times		quite boring issues
September 23	RickonTV.com		good laughs, but not much more
September 24	Nyack Journal News		dumb, dull
September 26	Binghamton Press & Sun-Bulletin	N/A	Gay role for Seton grad
October 1	Entertainment Weekly	N/A	Sofer provides most of the yuks
October 5	Entertainment Weekly		pretty watchable
October 15	Just Out (Portland)		feels like a retread
October 22	Raleigh News & Observer	N/A	divorce is the centerpiece
October 25	Time Magazine	N/A	gay characters have become quietly hot
November 30	ABC Soaps in Depth	N/A	Venus in Love
December 10	Hollywood Reporter	N/A	congrats Alan Ball